Panzer wrote:Sorry AnonAmbientLight, but if everything would be so obvious and easy to tell there wouldn't be discussions about those specific rules in the first place.
Panzer wrote:If YOU know all the answers and your local group plays along then that's fine. But don't just assume it's the same everywhere else because it clearly is not.
Panzer wrote:Imo the list from Gragagrogog is a good one and well worded for the most part so GW should get an idea which parts still need clarification.
Panzer wrote:Also: since those are rules that we noticed need clarification because people DO interpret things differently,
Panzer wrote:there is NO point in starting a discussion about every single one of those right here. You won't convince everyone of your "correct" interpretation because it didn't work before already. Discussing these rules is not the point of this thread and would only clutter it.
Actually there is a point. If you're looking to get things clarified, then the actual uncertain questions should be asked. Am I wrong? Isn't that what this thread is about? If GW could only answer three questions on this list, are you SURE you want one of those to be "It says Longstrike buffs Hammerheads. The Core Rule book states that models that buff other models buff themselves as long as they have the keyword. Longstrike has the Hammerhead keyword. Does this mean that Longstrike can buff himself?" Seriously?
I'm not starting a conversation on every single one of those right here. I'm actually pointing out the ones that are easily explained if you read the rules, understand basic language composition, and "order of operations". It's why I said, at the top of my post, "Some of these can be answered already."
AnonAmbientLight wrote:Gragagrogog wrote:AnonAmbientLight wrote:Some of these can be answered already.
Yes, I know these can be answered. I have an answer for.... hold on... don't fly off your chair... ALL OF THEM.
Really? I missed all that. Most of your answers consisted of "No one can decide, so we are going to ask."
But most of the questions have pretty clear and definitive answers. The last three, and the Tidewall example are really the only questions. Everything else is explained.
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 2 guests